I understand being penalized for a missed loan EMI, as that’s a debt. But my SIP is a voluntary investment. Why does my bank penalize me for failing to make a voluntary payment? It feels unethical.
While it certainly feels unfair to be penalized for a failed voluntary investment, banks justify the charge from a procedural standpoint. They view the penalty not as a punishment for failing to invest, but as a standard fee for the operational failure of a pre-authorized transaction that you initiated.
The Customer’s Perspective: A Penalty on a Voluntary Action
I was discussing this with my friend who recently had a small SIP bounce and was hit with a large penalty. His argument was exactly the same as yours. He said, “I wasn’t defaulting on a loan or breaking a credit agreement. I just didn’t have spare funds to invest that month. To be charged a heavy penalty for this seems to go against the entire spirit of encouraging people to save and invest.” This is the core of the ethical argument against the charge.
The Bank’s Perspective: A Charge for a Failed Service
A banker I know explained the bank’s official viewpoint. He said, “The penalty is not for the missed investment; it is for the failed service.” He elaborated that when you set up a SIP, you give the bank a standing instruction via a NACH mandate. The bank’s automated system attempts to execute this instruction on the scheduled date. When it fails due to insufficient funds on your end, a specific operational process is triggered. The charge, he explained, is for this failed service attempt.
Is it Fair? The Debate on Proportionality
A financial journalist I spoke with believes the real ethical issue lies in the proportionality of the charge. He agrees that a small fee for a failed service is logical. However, he questions whether a high, fixed penalty of ₹500 is a fair and proportionate charge for a failed voluntary investment of ₹1,000, especially when the actual processing cost to the bank is negligible in the digital era. He argues that the high, fixed nature of the penalty, not the charge itself, is what many consider to be unethical.
1 Like